¿Why do I Keep losing customers to competitors who seem similar to me?

August 2025

Blanca Ruíz, BRS BRANDING STUDIO www.brsbranding.com /

Brand and Identity Design, Graphic Design, Product development and Style GuideDesign 

This is one of the most common problems my clients face: Losing customers to competitors who appear similar can be frustrating and confusing. If you’re asking ¿why do customers switch? you’re not alone

Many business owners face this challenge, and the root cause often lies in subtle but critical differences in brand strategy and identity that customers perceive—sometimes unconsciously. Here’s why it may be happening to you and what you should consider.

I am Blanca Ruíz, a brand alchemist, identity designer, and the head of BRS Branding.

Drawing from over 18 years of experience, I will reveal the most common factors that have consistently impacted my clients' success.

¿Why am I losing a lot of customers to competitors who are not as good as I am? 6 main reasons and how to fix it.

• Lack of Clear Differentiation: Your customers might find it hard to see what truly makes your business different or better than your competitors. When offerings seem identical, price or convenience often become the deciding factors and this is not a very good place to be in.

  
  

• Weak Brand Identity: If your brand doesn’t communicate a strong, memorable personality or values, it becomes easy for customers to overlook you in favor of competitors with more distinct or appealing brands.

  
  

• Inconsistent Messaging: Mixed or unclear messaging across your website, social media, advertising, and sales channels creates confusion and reduces trust.

  
  

• Poor Customer Experience: Competitors may provide smoother, friendlier, or more personalized experiences even if the products themselves are similar.

  
  

• Emotional Disconnect: Customers often buy based on emotion. If competitors connect better emotionally through storytelling, community-building, or brand voice, they win loyalty.

  
  

• Lack of Engagement: Competitors may engage more often or more effectively with customers, leveraging social proof, reviews, and active communication.

¿How to stop losing customers to competitors and how to retain them?

Based on my experience as brand consultant and identity desginer, I would say there is no direct answer. However the following measures are amongst the solutions to the problem:

Solutions to Stop Losing Customers to Competitors and retain them:

• Clearly Define Your Unique Value Proposition: When customers understand what makes your brand uniquely valuable, they are more likely to choose you over similar competitors. According to studies, "28% of consumers cite consistent branding as a key reason for loyalty—clarity in your brand message drives preference and retention. "

   (Emarsys 2025 )

  
  

  Most of my clients find it hard to define in a very short sentence their Value proposition, or as I call it: THE WOW FACTOR.

  
  

  When businesses understand what makes them unique and different and understand how that is relevant to their customers, sales are easier.

  
  

  If you or your own team struggles to articulate the value of your offer in a clear and straightforward manner, how can you expect your customers to understand and appreciate them?

  
  
  
  

• Create and Maintain a Strong, Consistent Brand Identity: Consistency across all customer touchpoints (website, social media, packaging, advertising) builds trust and recognition. Brands with consistent messaging see improved customer loyalty and retention, which can increase profits by 25% to 95% with just a 5% increase in retention rates.

  (ThinkImpact, "50+ Customer Retention Statistics 2025," October 2024.)

  
  

  Brand inconsistency often occurs when there is a lack of clear guidance. Identity manuals are frequently ignored, and in-house designers make decisions about the brand's appearance without adequate training or understanding of the brand's "essence."

  
  

  In reality, your brand identity SHOULD BE A POWERFUL TOOL to propel your company to success that works in harmony with your sales process and how you deliver your goods and services.

  
  

• Deliver Exceptional Customer Experience: Customers value seamless and personalized experiences.

  
  

  Branding is not only about how you look, it is about the overall experience your customers have while interacting with you. Data shows 86% of customers are more likely to stay loyal if they feel an emotional connection with customer service agents, and positive experiences can boost spending by up to 140%.

  (Sprinklr, "40+ Customer Retention Statistics to Know in 2025," December 2024.)

  
  

• Engage Customers Regularly: Active engagement through loyalty programs, personalized communication, and social media interaction keeps your brand top of mind. 79% of customers want to be rewarded for loyalty, and brands with strong loyalty incentives see higher repeat purchase rates.

  (Ecommercebonsay: "37+ Customer Retention Statistics For 2025: The Definitive List")

  
  

  One thing you can do is Implement Loyalty and Referral Programs. Incentives like points, discounts, VIP access, or referral rewards foster ongoing relationships and turn customers into advocates, leveraging word-of-mouth to grow your base while retaining existing customers.

  
  

• Invest in Employee Experience: Happy employees provide better service, which builds customer trust and retention. Companies with engaged employees often see improved customer satisfaction and loyalty.

  
  

  Your employees can make or break the experience. It's essential to train them to provide the memorable brand experience that has been carefully crafted for your customers.

  
  

• Regularly Measure and Adapt Brand Strategy: Use tools like Net Promoter Score (NPS) surveys and customer feedback to identify gaps and refine your strategy, ensuring it stays aligned with customer needs and market trends.

¿What other data can support that brand strategy is effective to stop losing customers to competitors?

• Existing customers spend 67% more on average than new customers.

• Increasing retention rates by 5% can boost profits by 25% to 95%.

• 62% of customers are willing to pay more for better customer experiences.

• 88% of customers who trust a brand become repeat buyers.

• 75% of consumers switch to brands with better loyalty programs.

  
  

By focusing on these areas driven by a well-defined and executed brand strategy, you can stop losing customers to competitors who seem similar and build lasting loyalty and growth for your business.

---

¿What to do next to define which strategies can help you business to stop losing clients to competitors?

What to do next?

• Read my blog post to find if you need a brandworkshop

• Book a call with me to see how can I help you according to the journey of your brand.

• Subscribe to our mailing list to receive notifications of our latest posts and monthly newsletter.

http://www.brsbranding.com